Homemade Toothpaste That Will Make You Smile

Homemade toothpaste recipe using only 5 natural ingredients. 

Orange Peppermint Homemade Toothpaste | DIY Beauty | Non Toxic | Healthy Living

Ever since I was a little girl, I’ve been sewing, cooking and whipping up crafts of all sorts. This craftiness certainly has had its advantages – saving money (why buy when you can make?), impressing friends (homemade gifts!) and generally keeping me out of trouble.

On the flip side, I’ve spent countless dollars on supplies for short-lived hobbies (hello metal-working and pottery classes) and have amassed large collections of things like fabric, beads and buttons that are currently collecting dust.

If any of this sounds familiar to you, then you’ll understand how someone like this would eventually be the kind of person who makes her own toothpaste.

It was bound to happen. First it was simple scrubs and masks. Then lip balms and body creams. Now homemade toothpaste. And it’s not because good natural toothpaste is not available – it is! But once a maker, always a maker and toothpaste was on my bucket list.

Is homemade toothpaste is on your bucket list too? 

Orange Peppermint Homemade Toothpaste | DIY Beauty | Non Toxic | Healthy Living


How to Make Homemade Toothpaste

Just so you know – I tried a lot of variations before I came up with a homemade toothpaste recipe that I liked. I knew I wanted to use bentonite clay as the base because of its ability to draw out toxins and deposit minerals on teeth – plus it is the primary ingredient in Earthpaste, a natural toothpaste I like a lot.

Variations using baking soda were a bit too harsh for me. The consistency of a version using only bentonite clay and essential oils was a bit odd. It was only when I added in a bit of coconut oil to the mix  that I got the flavor and consistency that I liked.

Feel free to mess around with this recipe to find your favorite combination!

Orange Peppermint Homemade Toothpaste

About the ingredients

(*affiliate links ahead)

One of the biggest advantages of making your own toothpaste is knowing what’s in it. This toothpaste recipe has only 5 natural ingredients – plus a bit of water to bind it all together. Don’t worry – you won’t go broke making this – these ingredients are inexpensive and could even save you money on toothpaste in the long run.

  • Bentonite clay – draws out toxins, reduces acidity in mouth, non-abrasive polisher and is full of minerals like calcium and magnesium that are good for teeth
  • Coconut oil – anti-bacterial and anti-fungal
  • Essential oils – anti-bacterial and fights plaque (I chose a blend of orange and peppermint)
  • Sea salt – natural cleanser and whitener
  • Stevia – natural sweetener

What’s not in this toothpaste? Fluoride, glycerin, sodium lauryl sulphate, triclosan, propylene glycol, carrageenan, saccharin, polyethylene, titanium dioxide and artificial colors and flavors.

Orange Peppermint Homemade Toothpaste | DIY Beauty | Non Toxic | Healthy Living

Orange Peppermint Homemade Toothpaste Recipe

Homemade toothpaste is super easy to make. Just mix all the ingredients together in a bowl – no need to heat anything up. Use the back of the spoon to break up any clumps of coconut oil.  (Note: bentonite clay reacts with metal and loses its effectiveness, so it is best to use a non-metal bowl and spoon for this project.)

As for flavor, the combination of orange and peppermint essential oils, along with a smidge of stevia give it a slightly sweet taste, along with that fresh mintiness you expect from toothpaste. Feel free to choose your own essential oil combination – cinnamon, clove, spearmint and lemon are popular toothpaste flavors too.

Because there are no preservatives, it is best to make a small batch that will be used up in about a month.

Store your homemade toothpaste in a small glass or plastic jar. I save and reuse jars from food and beauty products especially for my DIY concoctions – but Amazon sells 2-oz glass jars that are the perfect size for a batch of this toothpaste.

And if you’re wondering where that wooden toothbrush is from – it’s a MABLE bamboo toothbrush – love it!

Whether you’re a DIY addict or newbie, I have a feeling this toothpaste will make you smile!

Orange Peppermint Homemade Toothpaste
  • 2 Tablespoons powdered bentonite clay
  • 4 Tablespoons water
  • 1 Tablespoon coconut oil
  • ¼ teaspoon stevia powder
  • ⅛ teaspoon sea salt
  • 10 drops peppermint essential oil
  • 10 drops orange essential oil
  1. Mix powdered clay with water in a small, non-metal bowl, with a non-metal spoon.
  2. Add remaining ingredients and mix until well blended.
  3. Store in a glass or plastic jar.
  4. Shelf life about 1 month.


Do you love making stuff? What’s the most unusual DIY you’ve done?



(*If you make a purchase using an affiliate link, I may receive a small commission. Thank you for supporting Mindful Momma if you do!)


Homemade Lavender Calendula Skin Balm

How to Make Lavender Calendula Skin Balm // www.mindfulmomma.com

How to make homemade lavender calendula skin balm using only 5 natural ingredients. My skin has been so dry lately. Not sure if it's the change of season or what, but it seems more dry than it usually is in the winter. I've been "itching" for a skin balm with sticking power - one that stays on my skin for a while instead of … [Continue reading]

Easy DIY Gifts

Easy DIY Gifts

Attention procrastinators and non-crafty types! I'm here to tell you that homemade gifts don't have to be complicated and endless time-consuming. Even people who don't consider themselves the least bit crafty can pull off these easy DIY wins!   You may already have the ingredients in your cupboard for some of these gifts like sugar … [Continue reading]

3 Ways to Jumpstart Your Body Using Coffee (without drinking it)

3 Ways to Jumpstart Your Skin & Hair with Coffee via mindfulmomma.com

Aaaaaahh coffee! Just the smell of it perks me up. Whether or not you are a #coffeeaddict like me, there are ways you can give yourself a little extra boost for the day without actually drinking the stuff. Turns out the caffeine in coffee beans has all sorts of skin toning and beautifying properties. It acts as an energizer for tired … [Continue reading]

Top Blogs for DIY Beauty Products

Top Blogs for DIY Beauty Products including homemade skin care, cosmetics, bath products and more!

A roundup of the top blogs for DIY beauty products - with recipes for homemade skin care, cosmetics, bath products and everything in between. What are your reasons for making DIY beauty products? Maybe you're looking to eliminate toxic chemicals in your beauty products or to simplify your skincare routine? Perhaps you're on … [Continue reading]