How to Manage Halloween Candy with Kids

How to help kids manage Halloween candy so they can have fun and be healthy at the same time.

How to Manage Halloween Candy with Kids

Are you up to your ears in Halloween candy? Yeah, we are too. Like it or not, sweets season is officially upon us! By the time the Halloween candy is gone, we’ve got pumpkin pies and then it’s candy canes and countless other holiday sweet treats. So what’s a healthy parent to do?

I may receive commissions from purchases made through links in this article including Amazon Affiliates. Full Disclosure

How to Manage Halloween Candy Crazyness

Here are a few ideas for how to manage Halloween candy and other sweets and treats during the holiday season:

Swap it out

Have you ever heard of the switch witch? Apparently she visits  unsuspecting houses and swaps out healthier treats for crappy ones.  Some brave parents even pay money for each piece of candy the child hands over or substitute a toy for the entire candy stash. Where does the candy actually go after that? Why the office candy bowl of course – where treats magically disappear without worry of calories, preservatives or artificial dyes! Full disclosure: I have never done this (although I have been known to toss whatever is still left after a few weeks).

Set limits

No matter how old your kids are, it’s important to set some type of limit on candy consumption. Obviously, it’s going to be different depending on the age of the kids. When my kids were younger, I limited it to one or two pieces a day. Now that my kids are older, I don’t try to micro-manage the situation too much but I do ask them to limit it to 2 pieces after a meal. And call me the worst parent on the planet, but I let them have candy for breakfast on the day after Halloween. They must dream about candy all night long and they wake up completely obsessed! Oddly enough, I find that they get over the candy-mania after a couple of days and all-in-all they self-regulate pretty well.

Same goes for the rest of the holiday-season dessert overload. Teaching kids how to enjoy treats in moderation, as part of an otherwise healthy diet is key!

Take a break

So you let your kids go a little crazy on sweets for a while. Then you’ve got to cut back, which can be hard because sugar is a bit addictive in case you haven’t noticed. First, we cut the candy because that’s not something we keep around the house all year long. Then we cut back on having sweets after every meal. How about some fruit? Then, sometime after the holiday sugar season is finally over, we usually have a sweets-free week for the whole family. Getting off sugar completely is a great way to reset your system. The cravings go down and after that we can get by on homemade cookies and healthier treats. But then Valentine’s Day comes along….

Emphasize healthy eating

The last part of the story is that it’s important to model healthy eating habits for your kids. So don’t take away their candy and then down a couple of Cokes in front of them, OK? Our kids see us cooking healthy foods, reading labels and watching what we eat. We include veggies with every meal and the fruit bowl is always open for snack time. Talk to your kids about healthy foods and empower them to take charge of their health. Offer up some healthier snacks and do what you can to make healthy food fun!

My youngest son’s birthday is 6 days before Halloween, and I always view that as the beginning of sweets season. Now add all the Halloween candy and we’ve got a major sugar buzz going on around here. Bottom line is, I don’t try to deny it but I do limit it and yes, we’ll be having a sweets-free week in January!

How do you manage Halloween candy and other sweets in your house?

green & healthy wishes Micaela signature


  1. Yes! Couldn’t agree more on both the “don’t deny” and “candy for breakfast the morning after” fronts. My guys – now 18 and 19 – also soon self-regulated after a couple of days. Our golden retriever Oscar – well that was a different story. He delighted in munching on basketfuls of chocolate Easter eggs (foil and all) with no ill results.
    I used to freeze the chocolate eggs and bars and then bring some along on skiing trips. Worked like a charm.

    1. Kelly – Yikes! Glad to hear your dog survived his chocolate binges. Love the idea of freezing some candy for winter skiing or sledding trips!

  2. Our dentist will do buy-backs! Also, consider sending to our military or including in a stocking for operation Christmas child or other holiday donations.

    And, if your chocolate makes it that long, repurpose for holiday baking!

    1. Cool that your dentist will do buy-backs! Holiday donations is a great idea too – if it lasts that long without being eaten!

  3. Love your thoughts and suggestions! It’s so nice to know that I’m not the only one who battles this. We have largely worked it out by limiting—they start out with about 40 pieces, and then they get to choose their favorites and narrow it down to 10 that they can keep—the rest either goes in the garbage (yucky gummy candy) or to my husband’s office (chocolates).
    Thanks for the work you do. 🙂

    1. Glad you liked the post Shayne. I’m guessing your kids are a lot younger than mine. Now that they are tweens/teens I could never limit them to 10 pieces! To me, the most important thing is to make sure they understand that candy is OK in moderation but healthy eating everyday is the key to living a healthy life!

  4. Wonderful advice, the day after Halloween is always the hardest but I find my kids don’t care so much about the candy as they do the fun of dressing up and trick or treating with their friends, so when their candy disappears they don’t care.

    1. Ha – you are lucky they don’t mind if you sneak away their candy. That doesn’t work for me anymore!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *